Leibenstein xefficiency theory 11 when an input is not used effectively the difference between the actual output and the maximum output attributable to that input is measure of degree of xefficiency. As a concept xinefficiency is similar to technical inefficiency. The objective is to assess whether different ownership types and banking reforms affect xefficiency. Leibenstein argued that reasonable decreases in productive xefficiency would likely. Leibenstein in formulating his x efficiency theory distinguished himself from the neoclassicals. Banking institutions were badly hit by the crisis as they were burdened with high levels of non. Do mergers provide real benefits to acquiring firms. Xefficiency by harvey leibenstein at the core of economics is the concept of efficiency. The focus of the studies are the effects of mega mergers on xefficiency, the effects of the tarp. At the time, i was writing the dissertation for my ph. This part makes clear that the xefficiency is a source of adding value to an output and.
Leibenstein 1966 argues that competition can reduce x. Grant revenues do not force health centers to have an efficient business model, but rather to compete for more grant funding. United states and their development after a merger. Employing the stochastic frontier approach, this paper investigates cost xefficiency in chinas banking sector over the period 19852002. Katona, simon, and leibensteins xefficiency theory. If you need to print pages from this book, we recommend downloading it as a pdf. Xefficiency is the degree of efficiency maintained by individuals and firms under conditions of imperfect competition.
X inefficiency theory explains that this is due to distortion of market competition that occurs with grant revenues. Harvey leibenstein 1922 february 28, 1994 was a ukrainianborn american jewish economist. Allocative efficiency vs x efficiency harvey leibenstein. But if theory pretends only to give an account of particular, peculiar and special moments such as may be scarcely ever attained in fact and repudiates any hope of connecting them by. Critical contribution were made by harvey leibenstein to the theory of the firm through his development of efficiency wage and xefficiency theories. Forward to first edition by harvey leibenstein xiii. One of his most important contributions to economics was the concept of xefficiency and the critical minimum effort thesis in development economics. Agenda 2 classification an economic theory risk bearing theory of knight innovation theory of schumpeter leibenstein xefficiency theory harvard school theory theory of market equilibrium by hayek mcclellands achievement motivation theory theory of change theory of adjustment of price theory.
Unfortunately none of these studies explicitly examines the effect of mergers on xefficiency. The beginnings of behavioral economics sciencedirect. Leibensteins xefficiency theory leibenstein identifies two main roles for the entrepreneur. The following section discusses some concepts of efficiency commonly used in bank efficiency studies, such as economic efficiency, technical efficiency, and allocative efficiency. Unfortunately, this book cant be printed from the openbook. Akerloffs work included issues of rationality, work norms, and asymmetric information in both more and less developed countries.
Market actors presumably monitor such evolution and adjust their propensity to merge and the identity of merger partners accordingly. Fqhcs heavy reliance on grant funding was associated with decreased technical efficiency in fqhcs. Full text of entrepreneurship theories and their use in. General x efficiency theory and economic development harvey leibenstein economic development series. The case for repeal of iowas certificate of need law. In the following years, he elaborated this theoretical background and developed a larger general x. I was advised by professor millard hastay a member of my committee to look at leibensteins new book, beyond economic man. After considering and explaining the main elements of the x efficiency theory the paper continues with a closer view on it. Merger enforcement policy evolves over time in response to changes in economic theory and case law. Xinefficiency is the difference between efficient behavior of firms assumed or implied by economic theory and their observed behavior in practice. Perelman 2011 do people still read leibensteins fascinating 1966 article allocative efficiency vs.
Leibenstein, founder of xefficiency theory, and my mentor, who i miss very much. According to leibenstein, by growth agents we mean those individuals who have the capacities to carry out the growth contributing activities. As a concept x inefficiency is similar to technical inefficiency. Perelman notes that in the 1970s, this article was the thirdmost cited paper in all of the social sciences. One has to distinguish the xefficiency concept from the theory intended to explain it.
In this chapter, we will investigate the individuals effort decision, the individual as a group member, group behavior, and some elements that compose the external environment and that influence the firms degree of xefficiency. Basically, x efficiency is the degree of inefficiency in the use of resources within the firm. Microeconomic theory is concerned with allocative efficiency. Ipsative and objective limits to human behavior 245 acknowledgments the basic ideas pertaining to the ipsative theory of behavior discussed here have been developed jointly with klaus foppa, professor of psychology at the university of bern. The concepts of xinefficiency were introduced by harvey leibenstein the degree of efficiency maintained by individuals and firms under. While such a prospective balancing test is laudable in theory, this article. However, entrepreneurial theory is an exotic product that is rooted in western culture. If we combine our theory with what we could agree are prob. Linking entrepreneurship and economic growth mafiadoc.
Conliskwhy bounded rationality rationality economic. Firms may be exploiting greater xefficiency efficiency hypothesis or. According to the neoclassical theory of economics, under perfect. Xinefficiency theory explains that this is due to distortion of market competition that occurs with grant revenues. In technical terms, x efficiency refers to the deviations from the production efficient frontier that depicts the maximum attainable. Essentially, he is suggesting that information differences, principalagent contracting problems, and many. The xefficiency theory is a theory developed by harvey leibenstein 1994. Stigler, in his wellnamed xistence of xefficiency gated pdf, argues that we need to be really careful here. Full text of entrepreneurship theories and their use in rural development. Types of entrepreneurship routine entrepreneurship innovational entrepreneurship role of entrepreneurship input completion gap filling. Both the pdf i submitted to the publisher and the beautiful cover design are the work of gary chartier. Leibenstein in formulating his xefficiency theory distinguished himself from the neoclassicals.
In finance, talebs black swan theory is acknowledged in the discussion of tail risks. The university of minnesota is committed to the policy that all persons shall have equal access to its programs, facilities, and employment without regard to race, religion, color, sex, national origin. The problem is that just claiming waste is really a broad attack on a fundamental premise of economics, profit maximization. Do people still read leibensteins fascinating 1966 article allocative efficiency vs. Pdf critical contribution were made by harvey leibenstein to the theory of. Business certificate of need health facilities laws, regulations and rules models remedies. Leibenstein originated the concept of x inefficiency because of a belief that there is nothing technical about the most substantial sources of nonallocative inefficiencies in organizations. General xefficiency theory and economic development harvey. Department of economics, university ofcalifornia, berkeley, ca x. Leibenstein insisted that absent strong competitive pressure, firms are unlikely to use their resources efficiently.
Other peoples lack of effort and the consequent inefficiency of the organizations that employ them, create opportunities for entrepreneurs. In our view, the issue of whether and how mergers, through their effect on competition in the product market, affect the xefficiency of firms. The concept of xinefficiency was introduced by harvey leibenstein. Mergers, agency costs, and social welfare the journal of. Leibenstein was one of the first economists in recent decades to explore behavioral economics. A twostage regression model is estimated to identify the significant variables influencing xefficiency. Empirical evidence has been accumulating that suggests that the problem of allocative efficiency is trivial. Harvey leibenstein is most famous for introducing the xefficiency concept 1966, roughly a catchall term for the notion that ideal technical efficiency is frustrated in reality by people and organizations, due to a variety of factors, such as institutional. Though x efficiency theory makes use of productive efficiency, it relaxes the restrictive assumptions made by farrell 1957 on the nature of market structure. Agenda 2 classification an economic theory risk bearing theory of knight innovation theory of schumpeter leibenstein xefficiency theory harvard school theory theory of market equilibrium by hayek mcclellands achievement motivation theory theory of change theory of adjustment of price theory of entrepreneurial supply theory. Stigler, in his wellnamed xistence of xefficiency gated pdf, argues that we. The policy had always been to allow for market forces to dictate the pace of mergers.
Figure 19 railroad mergers and their welfare costs. In the last chapter, we focused on some elements of individual decision making that lead to xinefficiency. There are problems with both the individualist and the structuralist perspectives on. A dynamic theory of entrepreneurship was first advocated by schumpeter 1949 who considered entrepreneurship as the catalyst that disrupts the stationary circular flow of the economy and thereby initiates and sustains the process of development. By coming up with the x efficiency hypothesis, leibenstein was more radical than the other attempts that aimed to explain the empirical data. Critical contribution were made by harvey leibenstein to the theory of the firm through his development of efficiency wage and x efficiency theories. Posner a firm that is the only seller of a product or service having no close substitutes is said to enjoy a monopoly1 monopoly is an important concept to. Stein appealed to harvey leibensteins key concept of xefficiency. Nov 12, 2019 x efficiency is the degree of efficiency maintained by individuals and firms under conditions of imperfect competition. The behavioral economics of george akerloff and harvey. First, as harberger had previously shown, distortions like monopoly simply as a matter. After considering and explaining the main elements of the xefficiency theory the paper continues with a closer view on it. This was accomplished through his development of xefficiency theory, but not exclusively through xefficiency theory.
In his 1966 seminal article on xe theory leibenstein said. Though xefficiency theory makes use of productive efficiency, it relaxes the restrictive assumptions made by farrell 1957 on the nature of market structure. If mergers do provide real benefits, as the literature of industrial organizations and strategic management suggest, then why havent the empirical studies found any evidence of real benefits. Harvey leibenstein, and an anomaly called xefficiency. Mergers among the most xefficient banks reduced costs by. Sep 30, 20 fqhcs heavy reliance on grant funding was associated with decreased technical efficiency in fqhcs. The western theory of entrepreneurial theory is relatively mature, and a corresponding entrepreneurial theory system has been formed, but the environment it forms is completely in the western cultural context, and it does not apply to confucian scenes that are significantly different from western culture. Xefficiency society for the advancement of behavioral economics. So in many ways this is a collaborative product, and i owe my readers a debt of gratitude. Pdf effort discretion and economic agency and behavioral. By coming up with the xefficiency hypothesis, leibenstein was more radical than the other attempts that aimed to explain the empirical data. Leibenstein, general xefficiency theory and economic development, new.
Leibenstein originated the concept of xinefficiency because of a belief that there is nothing technical about the most substantial sources of nonallocative inefficiencies in organizations. This textbased pdf or ebook was created from the html version of this book and is part of the portable library of liberty. The critical minimum effort theory is based on the sum of positivesum activities and such activities are carried on by some growth agents. American microeconomist, industrial organization theorist and development economist at harvard. Entrepreneurs are the backbone of reform and opening up and have made significant contributions to the prosperity of chinas economy. General xefficiency theory and economic development harvey leibenstein economic development series. This passage is an overview of the theory of the entrepreneur, according to harvey leibenstein of harvard university written by leibenstein himself.
What is the similarity between its connotation and the western entrepreneur. Market theory predicts that all firms will be xefficient under perfect competition, because competitors would drive xinefficient. Leibensteins xefficiency theory offers a view of productivity that differs from traditional neoclassical economics in terms of whether inefficiency exists, what causes. Harvey leibenstein has written a major new book in microeconomic theory.
Xinefficiency is the divergence of a firms observed behavior in practice, influenced by a lack of competitive pressure, from efficient behavior assumed or implied by economic theory. Evaluation of the xefficiency theory in the supply. It occurs when technicalefficiency is not being achieved due to a lack of competitive pressure. Apr 26, 20 leibenstein regards entrepreneurship as a creative response to xefficiency. I also appreciate your ability to merge both old and new scholars. However, in his 1968 aer paper entrepreneurship and development,and in his 1978 book general xefficiency theory and development, leibenstein applied his theory of xefficiency to the study of development. Sep 02, 2016 xefficiency arises either because the firms resources are used in the wrong way or because they are wasted, that is, not used at al 15. Entrepreneurial activities pose a competitive threat to inefficient organizations.
Xefficiency arises either because the firms resources are used in the wrong way or because they are wasted, that is, not used at al 15. The author accomplishes this feat by introducing modern psychological concepts to microtheory, by. Posner a firm that is the only seller of a product or service having no close substitutes is said to enjoy a monopoly1 monopoly is an important concept to this article but even more important is the related but somewhat less. Generally spoken, x inefficiency means the difference between the optimal efficient behavior of business in theory and the observed behavior in practice. My dissertation was concerned with the role of attitudes in the schooltowork transition among young men. Basically, xefficiency is the degree of inefficiency in the use of resources within the firm. It is a sophisticated reorientation of microtheory that breaks away from the conventional, highly refined neoclassical theory, which in turn is in the direct line of descent from adam smiths the wealth of nations 1776. Anyone attempting to introduce to economics a nontraditional concept or idea is normally met by a cycle of critical challenges. The basic premises of leibensteins xefficiency and efficiency wage theories. This paper deals with the xefficiency theory and its influence on organizations. Harvey leibenstein is most famous for introducing the x efficiency concept 1966, roughly a catchall term for the notion that ideal technical efficiency is frustrated in reality by people and organizations, due to a variety of factors, such as institutional. General xefficiency theory and economic development.
But this immediately suggests a shift from traditional price theory to a. Nov 26, 2016 one has to distinguish the x efficiency concept from the theory intended to explain it. In the following years, he elaborated this theoretical background and developed a larger general x efficiency theory leibenstein, 1975, 1978a, 1978b. Yet it is hard to escape the notion that efficiency in some. So, in the context of confucian culture, how is the concept of entrepreneurs defined. Critical view on leibensteins xefficiency theory university of. From concept totheory contrary to standard theory, firms do not use their internal resources labor, capital, and information with optimum efficiency. Enacting risk in independent technological innovation. It is worth mentioning that his initial presentation of the theory of xefficiency had nothing to do with the study of development. New directions in austrian economics online library of. This part makes clear that the x efficiency is a source of adding value to an output and. Other aspects than those dealt with here are presented in frey and foppa 1986 and foppa 1987.
982 1558 232 1168 721 692 749 1428 583 792 1016 1448 769 904 1004 969 1429 1077 545 477 357 110 1542 658 89 1464 300 237 1408 728 61 973 403 440 580 453